The Modern Milkman logo
The Modern Milkman logo
Sign in
Sign in
  • Weekly menu
  • Our products
  • Our suppliers
  • How it works
  • Our story
  • Help
  • Login / Register
  • Our products
  • How it works
  • Our suppliers
  • Help
  • Our Company

  • Our story
  • Our suppliers
  • Farm tours
  • Become a supplier
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Legal
  • Help center

  • How it works
  • FAQs
  • Contact us
  • Sales team

Follow us on social media

© 2026 The Modern Milkman

Home >
Products >
Fall Essentials >
Centerville Pumpkin Pie

Centerville Pumpkin Pie

Centerville Pumpkin Pie

VegetarianVegetarian

Vegetarian

Frequently Asked Questions

Centerville Pies are made in Centerville, Massachusetts, a bakery with a long-standing reputation for quality pies and baked goods across New England.

Yes. Centerville Pies are baked with care using quality ingredients and time-honored recipes, delivering the kind of homemade taste and texture that sets them apart from anything you'd find pre-packaged on a supermarket shelf.

Keep Centerville Pies refrigerated at all times and consume within a few days of delivery for the best flavor and texture. Enjoy at room temperature or warmed through for the best experience.