The Modern Milkman logo
  • Weekly menu
  • Our products
  • Our suppliers
  • How it works
  • Our story
  • Help
  • Login / Register
The Modern Milkman logo
Get started link
Get started link
  • Our products
  • How it works
  • Our suppliers
  • Help
  • Our Company

  • Our story
  • Our suppliers
  • Farm tours
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Legal
  • Cookie Policy
  • Help center

  • How it works
  • FAQs
  • Contact us
  • Sales team

Follow us (and your dreams)

© 2025 The Modern Milkman

Mrs. Miller's Homemade Jams

Robinson's eggs

Our family got our start cooking jams, jellies, and butters in stock pots on mom's kitchen stove. The heartwarming smell of simmering apple butter wafting through the entire house is forever a part of our childhood memories. In the second generation almost 30 years later, not much has really changed at Mrs. Miller’s. The kettles may have grown a bit larger, and the selection of flavors has increased. But the old-time recipes, simple fresh ingredients, and the delicious homemade taste remain a staple in every hand-scooped batch, which are still canned on our home acres in Ohio’s Amish Country. We believe authentic homemade jams should stand out from other options in the market, which is why we choose to make our jams with fresh wholesome fruits, real cane sugar, and GMO- free ingredients. One of our highest compliments that we regularly receive from our customers is that our butters and jams "taste just like what I remember from my grandma’s cooking." Although we began with the traditional flavors such as apple butter, strawberry, and black raspberry, today our customers enjoy over 70 of our different varieties of jams, jellies, & butters. Some of our unique varieties include flavors such as guava, tomato, mint and even dandelion jelly, which derives its popular flavor from the yellow dandelion blossoms picked in local fields during the spring. There’s also a no sugar lineup, pepper jellies, and so many more to choose from. No matter your favorite flavor, Mrs Miller’s is sure to carry it and we promise you it will taste just like you remembered it from your grandmother’s kitchen.

A Sustainable Relationship

We work with real farmers and a network of independent suppliers who provide fresh groceries. This allows us to keep supply chains short, treat everyone fairly and reduce unnecessary waste.

Crystal Springs Creamery

Crystal Springs Creamery

Dam Good English Muffins

Dam Good English Muffins

Brightside Brew

Brightside Brew

Latremore Pine Ridge Farm

Latremore Pine Ridge Farm

Mrs. Miller's Homemade Jams

Mrs. Miller's Homemade Jams

Sourdough Haven

Sourdough Haven

Top Flight Pasta

Top Flight Pasta

Martin Rosol's

Martin Rosol's

Cortney's Modern Dipper

Cortney's Modern Dipper

Smith's Country Cheese

Smith's Country Cheese

Kelly's Family Foods

Kelly's Family Foods

Between Rounds Bagels

Between Rounds Bagels

Minerva Dairy

Minerva Dairy

Stani Dairy

Stani Dairy

LuAnn's Bakery

LuAnn's Bakery

Omar Coffee

Omar Coffee

Zuppardi's Apizza

Zuppardi's Apizza

Walnut Creek Foods

Walnut Creek Foods

Liuzzi Cheese

Liuzzi Cheese

Rose Sisters Chips

Rose Sisters Chips

Lyman Orchards

Lyman Orchards

Hartford Baking Co.

Hartford Baking Co.

Yosi Kitchen

Yosi Kitchen

Bear's BBQ

Bear's BBQ

The Modern Milkman: Convenience with a conscience.