The Modern Milkman logo
  • Weekly menu
  • Our products
  • Our suppliers
  • How it works
  • Our story
  • Help
  • Login / Register
The Modern Milkman logo
Get started link
Get started link
  • Our products
  • How it works
  • Our suppliers
  • Help
  • Our Company

  • Our story
  • Our suppliers
  • Farm tours
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Legal
  • Cookie Policy
  • Help center

  • How it works
  • FAQs
  • Contact us
  • Sales team

Follow us (and your dreams)

© 2025 The Modern Milkman

Omar Coffee

Robinson's eggs

Many years ago, during a tumultuous time in the northern corner of Constantinople, with war and unrest on the cusp, John Costas left his beautiful homeland for the United States of America, in pursuit of the American dream. John came through Ellis Island, started as a dishwasher at the Plaza Hotel, worked as a baker, and ultimately started his own business. The United States offered him freedom and opportunity – a place where his ambition could climb as high as the sky, and hard work was the means of getting there.Aroma Coffee was formed in 1937, later to become the Omar Coffee Company. John started with a single blend of coffee and a simple vision: buy premium green coffee beans, slow roast them to perfection, and always deliver superior freshness and personalized service to all customers. The dream became much more vivid when he married Sultana. Their two sons, Steve and Nick, eventually entered into the world of coffee as well. While other children spent their summers playing ball, these boys were roasting, packing, grinding and learning the coffee business – how to buy, what to buy, and the best way to ensure that the customer received the freshest quality product. As the distinctive aroma of freshly roasted coffee beans spread up and down the streets of Hartford’s Franklin Avenue, so did John’s business.In 1955, John’s son, Steve Costas, took over the business and continued to build Omar’s reputation for quality coffee throughout the state of Connecticut. Steve, once known in Hartford as the “Juan Valdez of Franklin Avenue,” continued with his father’s vision. The product line has since multiplied and diversified, yet the timeless philosophy remains the same.  Awareness for sustainability has also become an important factor. Omar Coffee currently offers fair trade, organic and rainforest alliance coffees, keeping environment and social responsibility at the forefront. In its fourth generation, Omar Coffee Co. continues to steadily grow. In our 80th year, we celebrate hard work, progress and achievement, all while still holding true to tradition and trust.

A Sustainable Relationship

We work with real farmers and a network of independent suppliers who provide fresh groceries. This allows us to keep supply chains short, treat everyone fairly and reduce unnecessary waste.

Crystal Springs Creamery

Crystal Springs Creamery

Dam Good English Muffins

Dam Good English Muffins

Brightside Brew

Brightside Brew

Latremore Pine Ridge Farm

Latremore Pine Ridge Farm

Mrs. Miller's Homemade Jams

Mrs. Miller's Homemade Jams

Sourdough Haven

Sourdough Haven

Top Flight Pasta

Top Flight Pasta

Martin Rosol's

Martin Rosol's

Cortney's Modern Dipper

Cortney's Modern Dipper

Smith's Country Cheese

Smith's Country Cheese

Kelly's Family Foods

Kelly's Family Foods

Between Rounds Bagels

Between Rounds Bagels

Minerva Dairy

Minerva Dairy

Stani Dairy

Stani Dairy

LuAnn's Bakery

LuAnn's Bakery

Omar Coffee

Omar Coffee

Zuppardi's Apizza

Zuppardi's Apizza

Walnut Creek Foods

Walnut Creek Foods

Liuzzi Cheese

Liuzzi Cheese

Rose Sisters Chips

Rose Sisters Chips

Lyman Orchards

Lyman Orchards

Hartford Baking Co.

Hartford Baking Co.

Yosi Kitchen

Yosi Kitchen

Bear's BBQ

Bear's BBQ

The Modern Milkman: Convenience with a conscience.