The Modern Milkman logo
  • Weekly menu
  • Our products
  • Our suppliers
  • How it works
  • Our story
  • Help
  • Login / Register
The Modern Milkman logo
Get started link
Get started link
  • Our products
  • How it works
  • Our suppliers
  • Help
  • Our Company

  • Our story
  • Our suppliers
  • Farm tours
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Legal
  • Cookie Policy
  • Help center

  • How it works
  • FAQs
  • Contact us
  • Sales team

Follow us (and your dreams)

© 2025 The Modern Milkman

Zuppardi's Apizza

Robinson's eggs

The rich history of Zuppardi’s Apizza began in New Haven, CT with Dominic Zuppardi. Having learned his trade on the southern coast of Italy, Dominic was a master bread-baker in New Haven throughout the 1920s. He worked in a variety of bakeries making artisan Italian breads, as well as “abeetz”, now well known as apizza. In 1932, Dominic decided to open his own shop, Salerno’s Bakery, on Donnelly Place in New Haven. Two years later, in 1934, Dominic moved his business to Union Avenue in West Haven, CT. Union Ave has been the home of Zuppardi’s ever since!In the late 1940s, Dominic became ill due to a stroke and could no longer fulfill the needs of the bakery. Dominic’s son, Anthony Zuppardi, decided to step in. After completing his duty as a cook in the Navy during World War II, Anthony took over the daily operations of the business. He recognized the popularity of the bakery’s pizza and decided to make it his primary focus. At first, he made a small variety of pizzas, including the traditional plain pie, consisting of tomato sauce and grated Pecorino Romano cheese. After seeing success, the menu grew.Anthony expanded his menu by adding a variety of meat and vegetable toppings, most notably, his homemade Italian fennel sausage. His customers loved it immediately and the demand for his pizza grew exponentially! Anthony inevitably made the decision to leave the bread business behind entirely and to serve pizza only. In 1947, he changed the name of the shop from Salerno’s Bakery to Zuppardi’s Apizza.As decades passed, Anthony and his family worked passionately to accommodate their customers. The restaurant became a cornerstone in West Haven and is widely considered an institution within the subject of New Haven-style pizzerias. Anthony Zuppardi passed away in 1988, but his legacy lives through his children and grandchildren who continue to operate Zuppardi’s today.

A Sustainable Relationship

We work with real farmers and a network of independent suppliers who provide fresh groceries. This allows us to keep supply chains short, treat everyone fairly and reduce unnecessary waste.

Crystal Springs Creamery

Crystal Springs Creamery

Dam Good English Muffins

Dam Good English Muffins

Brightside Brew

Brightside Brew

Latremore Pine Ridge Farm

Latremore Pine Ridge Farm

Mrs. Miller's Homemade Jams

Mrs. Miller's Homemade Jams

Sourdough Haven

Sourdough Haven

Top Flight Pasta

Top Flight Pasta

Martin Rosol's

Martin Rosol's

Cortney's Modern Dipper

Cortney's Modern Dipper

Smith's Country Cheese

Smith's Country Cheese

Kelly's Family Foods

Kelly's Family Foods

Between Rounds Bagels

Between Rounds Bagels

Minerva Dairy

Minerva Dairy

Stani Dairy

Stani Dairy

LuAnn's Bakery

LuAnn's Bakery

Omar Coffee

Omar Coffee

Zuppardi's Apizza

Zuppardi's Apizza

Walnut Creek Foods

Walnut Creek Foods

Liuzzi Cheese

Liuzzi Cheese

Rose Sisters Chips

Rose Sisters Chips

Lyman Orchards

Lyman Orchards

Hartford Baking Co.

Hartford Baking Co.

Yosi Kitchen

Yosi Kitchen

Bear's BBQ

Bear's BBQ

The Modern Milkman: Convenience with a conscience.